Cross-Stitching and Slot-Stitching
Stitching Concrete Pavement Cracks and Joints
There are two stitching methods used to repair and strengthen cracks or joints in concrete pave- ment. The first, and most common, is cross- stitching. Cross-stitching uses deformed tie bars epoxied or grouted into holes drilled at an angle through a crack. The second, slot-stitching, uses deformed tie bars grouted into slots cut across a joint or crack. Each technique is beneficial for certain circumstances. Recommendations on where to use these methods are outlined in this special report.
Stitching is applicable for a number of situations where strengthening joints or cracks is required. Among these are:
- Strengthening longitudinal cracks in slabs to prevent slab migration and maintain aggregate interlock
- Mitigating omission of tie bars from longitudinal contraction joints due to construction error
- Tying roadway lanes or shoulders that are separating and causing a maintenance problem
- Tying centerline longitudinal joints which are starting to fault
- Strengthening keyed joints for heavy loads (aircraft, gantry cranes, straddle carriers, etc.)
The first reported attempt at cross-stitching was performed by the Corps of Engineers, Waterways Experiment Station. The Corps performed a study(1) on strengthening keyed longitudinal joints for airport pavements placed on low-strength subgrades in 1971. Their report outlines testing of a variety of joint strengthening methods and concludes that cross-stitching is one of the best strengthening techniques.
In the study, an 11-inch concrete pavement was placed directly on a low-strength clay subgrade with a keyed longitudinal construction joint. Amongst other methods, drilling holes at 45 degrees through the joint and epoxying 12.75-inch long, 1-inch diameter bars into the holes strengthened the keyed joint. A 360,000-pound, 12-wheel gear load, simulating one main gear of a C-5A aircraft, was used to test the joint. At the end of the test, the cross-stitched joint withstood the repeated loading even better than the surrounding pavement. The report concludes that cross-stitching is viable and effective.
The first known use of cross-stitching on a U.S. highway was in 1985 by the Utah Department of Transportation.(2) Engineers used cross-stitch- ing to strengthen uncontrolled cracks on a new section of I-70 through the mountains of central Utah. The pavement was a 9-inch plain jointed concrete pavement resting on a 4-inch thick lean concrete base. Much of the uncontrolled cracking in the pavement was reflection cracking in areas where the surface concrete bonded to the lean concrete subbase. The cracks of major concern were the longitudinal cracks in or near the wheel tracks in the driving lanes. At that time, ACPA recommended replacing the shattered slabs (slabs with 3 or more cracks) and using cross-stitching only for longitudinal cracks within the wheel paths. In the spirit of testing the limits of cross-stitching, the project team’s decision was to perform only two methods of repair regardless of the degree of uncontrolled cracking:
- Epoxy non-working joints close to cracks.
- Cross-stitch the longitudinal joints in or near the wheel tracks in the selected areas.
A total of 1,081 holes were drilled on the project, which resulted in about 1,800 feet of cross-stitching.
A review of the I-70 project in February 2000, after 15 years of service, found the project to be in generally good condition, with some faulting across undoweled transverse contraction joints. The performance of cross-stitched cracks was favorable in most areas. In some areas, spalling was noted between the holes drilled for the cross-stitch tiebars; cracks also traced from hole-to-hole in these areas. However, the cross-stitch cracks performed well overall, preventing lane separation and minimizing the settlement of the slabs.
Since the first known cross-stitching project in Utah, many roadway agen- cies are known to have employed stitching (see map).
Cross-stitching is a repair technique for longitudinal cracks and joints that are in reasonably good condition. The purpose of cross-stitching is to maintain aggregate interlock and provide added reinforcement and strength to the crack or joint. The tie bars used in cross-stitching prevent the crack from vertical and horizontal movement or widening.
Cross-stitching uses deformed tie bars inserted into holes drilled across a crack at angles of 35 to 45 degrees depending upon the slab thickness. A 0.75-inch diameter bar is sufficient to hold the joint tightly together to enhance aggregate interlock. The bars are spaced 24 to 36 inches from center to center and alternate from each side of the crack. A 36-inch spacing is adequate to effectively repair highways or roadways. Heavy truck traffic or airplane traffic requires a 24-inch bar spacing for added strength.
Any separated joints or cracks should not be sealed prior to cross-stitching as drilling through the material is not possible or at the very least extremely difficult.
The process of stitching requires the following steps and considerations:
- Drill holes at an angle so that they intersect the longitudinal crack or joint at about mid-depth. (It is important to start drilling the hole at a consistent distance from the crack or joint, in order to consistently cross at mid-depth.)
- Select a drill that minimizes damage to the concrete surface, such as a hydraulic powered drill; Select a drill diameter no more than 0.375 inches larger than the tie bar diameter. Choose a gangmounted drill if higher productivity is needed for larger jobs.
- Airblow the holes to remove dust and debris after drilling.
- Inject epoxy into the hole, leaving some volume for the bar to occupy the hole. (Pouring the epoxy is acceptable for small quantities.)
- Insert the tie bar into hole.
- Remove excess epoxy and finish flush with the pavement surface.
Slot-stitching is a repair technique for longitudinal cracks or joints. Slot-stitching is an ex- tension of the more recent dowel bar retrofit technique, which is used to add dowel bars to existing transverse joints.(3)
The purpose of slot-stitching is to provide positive mechanical interconnection between two slabs or segments. The deformed bars placed in the slots hold the segments together, serving to maintain aggregate interlock and provide added reinforcement and strength to the crack or joint. These bars also prevent the crack or joint from vertical and horizontal movement or widening. Larger diameter bars (>1.0 inch) also serve to provide long-term load transfer capabilities.
Slot-stitching requires the following steps and considerations:
- Cut slots approximately perpendicular to the longitudinal joint or crack using a slot cutting machine or walk-behind saw. Unlike dowel bar retrofit, precision alignment is not critical since deformed bars will hold the joint tightly together preventing the slabs from separating.
- Prepare the slots by removing the concrete and cleaning the slot. If the slabs have separated, consider using a joint reformer and caulking the joint or crack to prevent backfill materials from flowing into the area between the slabs.
- Place deformed bars into the slot.
- Place backfill material into the slot and vibrate it so it thoroughly encases the bar. Select a backfill material that has very low shrinkage characteristic. (3)
- Finish flush with the surface and cure.
Which Stitching Method Should I Choose?
Either method is effective. However, cross- stitching generally holds these advantages over slot-stitching:
- Less intrusive to the slab
- Less exposed surface area
- Less backfill material
Contractors and agencies should evaluate the costs and use the method that provides the optimal combination of strength, installation time and cost. Because more materials are required, slot-stitching is generally more expensive than cross-stitching.
Is Stitching Needed for All Uncontrolled Cracks? How Do I Know if the Cracking is too Severe?
Stitching is an excellent non-intrusive procedure to repair uncontrolled longitudinal cracking. However, in some cases it may not be advisable or necessary. Some cracks can perform well simply by sealing and maintaining the crack properly.
Both methods of stitching are not intended for severely deteriorated cracks. If the cracks are in
moderate or fair condition, stitching is effective. Experience on Utah’s first-ever highway crossstitching project demonstrates that stitching is not a substitute for slab replacement if the degree of cracking is too severe.
Can I Stitch Transverse Cracks?
Do not stitch transverse cracks. Transverse cracks often form active boundaries to slabs or segments of concrete and undergo thermal expansion and contraction movements (opening and closing). Cross-stitching prevents opening or closing of joints and cracks. If joint movement is restrained, stresses can build within the slab and result in spalling and cracking near the ends of the bars. These effects have been ob- served on highway applications where stitching was tried on transverse working cracks.
Should I Move Drifted Slabs Together Before Stitching?
Do not attempt to move drifted slabs back into position against adjacent slabs. First, there is usually no real concern or maintenance expense if slabs drift apart. Therefore moving the slabs may be a waste of resources. Second, the mechanical energy required to push the slabs would make this impractical in most cases.
How Do I Connect Drifted Slabs?
Of primary concern in connecting slabs that have drifted apart is preventing the backfill (either epoxy or grout) from flowing into the space between slabs. To prevent this, clean and fill the space between the slabs before stitching. A sand-cement grout is a suitable backfill for this purpose. However, due to concern over FOD (Foreign Object Damage), this is not recommended at airport facilities.
Can I Use Cross-Stitching to Tie New Lanes?
Do not use cross-stitching to tie a new lane to an existing lane. Wherever possible, it is ad- vantageous to drill laterally into the side of an existing lane and then epoxy tie bars into the holes, rather than to use a diagonal configuration as in cross-stitching.
Is Slot Stitching Better Suited for Multi-Lane Cross-Sections?
There is no evidence that either stitching treatment is better when applied within a multi-lane cross-section. In theory, slot stitching may be better suited than cross-stitching for a crack in a panel tied to three or more lanes because it has a longer length of embedded steel to dis- tribute tensile stresses. However, there are no field experiences to substantiate this theoretical advantage and cross-stitching has performed well on multi-lane cross sections.
What Are the Backfill Material Requirements for Slot Stitching?
Backfill materials for slot stitching should have little or no shrinkage, should gain sufficient strength in the period before loading and should have a Coefficient of Thermal Expansion similar to the surrounding concrete. General requirements for rapid set materials for use in stitching can be found in the IGGA Guide Specification for Dowel Bar Retrofit located at www.IGGA.net.
How Do I Treat the Joint Adjacent to a Stitched Crack?
After stitching a longitudinal crack, it may be necessary to treat a nearby longitudinal joint. The primary concern is whether a crack has formed below the saw cut for the longitudinal joint. If a crack has occurred and the joint functions properly, then no treatment other than joint sealing is warranted. However, if there is no crack extending below the saw cut joint, then it is advantageous to fill the saw cut with epoxy to strengthen the slab at this location. If the joint is not functioning, but a joint sealant has already been installed, then no further action is recommended.
A careful review of the joint is necessary to render a decision on whether epoxy treatment is necessary. Several cores should be taken along the joint to determine the prevailing condition (cracked or un-cracked). If the joint warrants epoxy filling, then the following process obtains best results:
- Clean the saw cut with water. Allow reservoir to dry.
- Drill plug holes at any location where the crack crosses the non-functioning joint to a depth below the saw cut.
- Place compression plugs or cement grout plugs into plug holes.
- Pour epoxy into saw cut using properly sized nozzle. (Do not overfill.)
For more information on stitching concrete pavement, contact the International Grooving and Grinding Association at (518) 731-7450 or visit us on the web at www.igga.net.
- Burns, C.D., R.L. Hutchinson, “Multiple-Wheeled Heavy Gear Load Pavement Tests, Design, Construction, & Behavior Under Traffic,” (WES-TR-5-71-17, Waterways Experiment Station, Vicksburg, MS, Nov. 1971.
- Investigation of Pavement Cracking Utah I-70, Project ID-70-1(31)7 Clear Creek to Belknap, American Concrete Pavement Association, Arlington Heights, IL, 1985.
- Guide for Load Transfer Restoration, JP001P, American Concrete Pavement Association, Skokie, IL, 1998.
- Voigt, G.F., “Specification Synthesis and Recommendations for Repairing Uncontrolled Cracks that Occur During Concrete Pavement Construction,” Volume 2, Proceedings, Sixth International Purdue Conference on Concrete Pavement Design and Materials for High Performance, Indianapolis, IN, 1997, pp.13-28.